According to PYMNTS.com, Simon Properties CEO David Simon stated that the upcoming holiday season will serve as a critical testing ground for how tariff costs are distributed across the retail ecosystem. The company reported impressive third-quarter performance with funds from operations rising to $1.228 billion from $1.067 billion a year ago, while occupancy at U.S. malls and premium outlets increased to 96.4% from 96.2%. Base minimum rent per square foot rose 2.5% to $59.14, and retailer sales per square foot reached $742 for the trailing 12 months. PYMNTS Intelligence found that 1 in 3 U.S. consumers said retailers explicitly cited tariffs as the reason for higher prices, while another 25% heard vague references to “increased costs.” This sets the stage for a crucial holiday season that will reveal how much price pressure luxury retail can withstand.
Sponsored content — provided for informational and promotional purposes.
The Three-Way Tariff Distribution Challenge
The fundamental business challenge facing Simon and its luxury tenants involves a delicate three-way negotiation over who absorbs tariff costs. When David Simon states that costs will be “passed on to the supplier, some will be eaten by the retailer, and some will be passed along to the consumer,” he’s describing a complex value chain negotiation that will determine profit margins across the entire luxury retail ecosystem. The company’s strong financial performance provides some cushion for temporary cost absorption, but the holiday season will test whether luxury brands have sufficient pricing power to maintain margins without sacrificing sales volume. This becomes particularly critical for premium outlets, where the value proposition traditionally centers on discounted luxury goods.
Luxury Consumer Psychology in a Tariff Environment
The holiday shopping season represents a unique psychological moment where consumer price sensitivity often decreases due to gift-giving imperatives and seasonal traditions. However, luxury retailers face a particular challenge: their customers are sophisticated enough to recognize when price increases exceed normal inflation patterns. The fact that 33% of consumers already report retailers explicitly blaming tariffs suggests a growing awareness that could either justify higher prices or trigger resistance. For Simon’s premium outlet model, this creates a tension between maintaining the discount positioning that drives traffic and adjusting prices to reflect genuine cost increases from suppliers.
Real Estate Resilience Through Experience and Destination
Simon’s strategy of focusing on “destination” retail formats represents a fundamental shift in commercial real estate business models. Rather than competing on convenience or price—areas where e-commerce dominates—premium malls and outlets are increasingly positioning themselves as experience destinations. This approach creates a buffer against tariff pressures because the value proposition extends beyond mere product acquisition. When consumers visit a Simon property, they’re paying for an entire day out—dining, entertainment, and social experiences that cannot be replicated online. This experiential premium provides retailers with more flexibility to adjust prices without losing customer loyalty.
The Coming AI Commerce Disruption
David Simon’s comment that AI shopping agents will primarily impact “eCommerce shoppers” reveals both insight and potential blind spots in the company’s long-term strategy. While he’s correct that AI will initially transform online shopping, the physical retail implications are more nuanced. As AI agents become sophisticated at finding the best deals and managing household replenishment, the role of physical stores must evolve from transaction centers to brand immersion platforms. This actually plays to Simon’s strength in destination retail, but requires continued investment in creating environments worth visiting despite the convenience of AI-powered shopping. The challenge will be ensuring that premium outlets and malls offer experiences compelling enough to justify the trip when AI can handle routine purchasing.
Holiday 2024 as Retail’s Canary in the Coal Mine
The upcoming holiday season will serve as a critical barometer not just for Simon’s portfolio but for the entire luxury retail sector. Strong performance despite tariff-related price increases would signal that destination retail has successfully decoupled from pure price competition. Weakness, however, would indicate that even luxury consumers have their limits. Simon’s 4.8% dividend increase demonstrates confidence in underlying cash flows, but the true test comes when retailers must choose between absorbing costs or testing price elasticity during their most important selling period. The outcome will shape investment decisions across commercial real estate for years to come.
